It’s a call or letter that no owner of an American Express credit card wants to receive: a notice that American Express is putting your account under financial review.
Scan the Internet and you’ll find countless stories of cardholders who struggled to work with American Express, only to have their accounts closed after this financial review. What infuriates people most is that there seems to be no logical pattern for what triggers an American Express financial review.
Here’s the basics, though: When you sign up for an American Express card, you give your agreement that the company can conduct a financial review of your account at any time. You also agree that American Express can cancel your card for any reason that the company chooses.
Some say that unusually large purchases, or an uncharacteristically busy period with lots of charges, will trigger an American Express financial review. American Express, though, isn’t sharing trigger points with the general public.
What usually happens with such a financial review is that cardholders receive either a letter or a phone call telling them that their accounts are under review. During the review time — which can last several months — American Express will deactivate these consumers’ cards.
American Express will then ask for a series of financial documents, usually cardholders’ most recent federal income tax returns and their bank statements from the last three months. If cardholders don’t provide this information, American Express will close their accounts.
Many cardholders view this as an invasion of privacy. Why, they ask, are their bank statements and income-tax returns any business of American Express’? This is a legitimate point. But it’s also a moot one: Cardholders aren’t about to change American Express’ policies.
Cardholders, then, who come under financial review have two choices for how to deal with this intrusion: They can quickly gather their documents and send them, by fax, e-mail or regular mail, to American Express, or they can refuse to do so and walk away from their accounts.
It all depends upon how committed to their American Express cards consumers are. Some cardholders can imagine using any other type of card. Others are happy with any card that provides a similar interest rate and benefits.
Cardholders should consider where they fit before they decide how to react to an American Express financial review. If they’re able to find another card that provides the same or better benefits, then there’s little reason to go through what everyone agrees is a hassle-filled procedure from American Express.
Those who truly enjoy their American Express cards, though, have little choice but to participate in any way they can with American Express’ financial review procedures. Yes, it is a cumbersome and invasive process. But those cardholders who want to maintain their relationship with American Express have little choice but to comply.



Dan Rafter has contributed to such publications as the Washington Post, Chicago Tribune and BusinessWeek Online. He's also a frequent blogger on credit and financial issues.





November 8th, 2010 at 10:30 pm
It seems like Amex has been cracking down a lot lately… do you think this is justified since most people only have a charge card with them? I, for example, don’t feel the need to show income statements, tax filings, etc to a company that I pay my balance in full to every month. What do you think?
November 9th, 2010 at 12:15 am
Basil – I think there are a lot of people who feel the same way, luckily I have never been subjected to this however I’m sure it’s only a matter of time.
From the consumer standpoint there is no question that American Express is the most sought after and respected card company (and one of the hardest to get approved for, even Michael Arrington of TechCrunch had a problem getting approved – http://techcrunch.com/2010/10/25/damnit-amex-give-me-a-credit-card/ )
I think that this all carries over to the existing cardholders with the financial review – as it is really the only way they can find those who may have falsified info when they applied.
December 14th, 2010 at 11:46 pm
I just learned today that American Express put me under review. I have faxed them form 4506T as requested, but now I think I should just use another card. I have only had the card a few months and recently my husband used the card to make a down payment on a vehicle. They said I was under review becuase the authorized user uses the card more than the primary. I am a little frustrated upset because I really just set my bills up for auto pay with them etc.
December 17th, 2010 at 7:18 pm
There is a flip side to the arguement…people who have nothing to hide, have nothing to worry about. I think it’s smart what AMEX is doing. If only other card companies will follow suit. Think about it: let’s say you find yourself in a bind and all of a sudden take out a large cash advance on your card…yet you have never done that defore. Why wouldn’t AMEX call the transaction out? To AMEX the ability to pay comes into question with such a transaction. Same holds true with the guy who put a down payment for a car on AMEX…why not just put cash down?
The USA is the largest debtor nation on the planet and it’s comments like I have read here that scare the heck out of me…not the actions of AXEX. It’s obvious the last 2-years have taught some people here absolutely nothing. Here is a reality check for those still out of touch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nI-BIVWlc7A
December 24th, 2010 at 8:17 pm
Well after the review they explained what was going and it made sense. I spend more than I made according to our tax records so they just wanted to make sure they would get their money back. The only thing is now is we have a limit on the card, which is okay. Yeah my husband used the card because he likes the rewards he earns.
January 22nd, 2011 at 2:09 am
Pls tell me what to do in this situation:
I am holding Amex from this month itself and I have been requested financial review the Tax for 4605.
The issue is my last year income is like nothing. I was a student. It is the current income on basis on which I am spending. So, why they need my last year income ?
May 5th, 2011 at 4:50 pm
There is no flip-side to this – this is complete BS. Credit card companies have no business performing this type of background check for general credit card users. I know what many will say – this is a standard practice for things like business loans, purchasing a house – and in those situations, I totally agree. Those are large ticket transactions where detailed financial history is a key deciding factor. But for consumer credit card usage, this is ridiculous.
The only way this kind of thing changes is if people stop giving in and say no to their practice. Granted, it will take a bunch of folks but it has to start somewhere.
We just got flagged and simply put – C’ya AMEX. Frankly AMEX doesn’t offer anything that other good CCs don’t…
August 29th, 2011 at 8:23 pm
Amex put us under “financial review” also, even though our payments are made on time, in full EVERY month. I also refused to send my financial documents. In today’s growing epidemic of identity theft, I did not feel comfortable at all with this, especially since there was no just cause. Well, we received a letter telling us that not only did they close our account, that this circumstance may result in a negative reporting to the credit card bureaus! WHAT?! We were NEVER late…..! Can they legally give us a negative reporting even though we are not late and just refused to hand over very personal documents??